The case would span 1983-2009 before justice was served. Two men were sent to death row, wrongly convicted by "criminally overzealous" prosecution team. That was a key issue in the 2003 decision for a Death Penalty Moratoruim in IL. Brian Dugan was finally charged and tried for Jeanine's murder. He was serving life sentences for murdering two others. He killed: JEANINE NICARICO, AGE 10, FEBRUARY 25, 1983. DONNA SCHNORR, AGE 27, JULY 15, 1984. MELISSA ACKERMAN, AGE 7, JUNE 2,1985.